It’s frustrating to watch competitors win work when you know your service is better, but people can only judge what they can see. More often than not, the gap in how two businesses are perceived starts on their websites.

We speak to a lot of organisations who are puzzled and frustrated about why a competitor seems to be doing so much better than them. This is understandable, because they know they’re delivering a higher quality service, or better products, or they’re putting far more effort into things like sustainability than anyone else in their sector. Yet somehow it’s the other business that seems to win the bigger contracts, get mentioned more often and grow more quickly.
When we start looking into it, it often comes down to being seen as being better at what they do, and that perception is built through the website.
People can only judge what they can see
From the outside, it’s surprisingly hard to tell how good a business really is. A potential customer can’t sit in on your projects, look at the care that goes into your processes or see the hours your team puts in to get something right. What they can do is look at your website, and they’ll use it to build a story or fill in the gaps.
Research from the Stanford Web Credibility Project, which asked more than 2,600 people how they decided whether to trust a website, found that the design and overall look of a site was the thing people mentioned most often, coming up in 46.1% of their comments. Far fewer mentioned the information itself. People were, in effect, judging the quality of the business by the quality of what they could see on screen.
That first impression also happens very quickly. A study led by Gitte Lindgaard at Carleton University found that people form an opinion of a web page’s visual appeal within about 50 milliseconds, and that their snap judgement tended to match what they thought after looking for longer. By the time someone has read your first sentence, they’ve often already decided whether you seem like a business they’d be comfortable working with.
Most of the decision is made before anyone gets in touch
This matters more now than it used to, because buyers are doing a lot of their thinking on their own before they ever speak to you. The 6sense Buyer Experience Report found that buyers are nearly 70% of the way through their purchasing process before they engage with a supplier, and that 81% of them already have a preferred supplier in mind by the time they make contact.
So if you’re relying on the conversation to show people how good you are, there’s a fair chance you won’t get the opportunity. The shortlist has often been written by the time anyone picks up the phone, and it’s been written largely on the basis of what people found when they looked you up. A competitor with a clearer, more confident website can be on that list ahead of you without ever having had to prove they deliver better results.
Being better isn’t the same as looking better
One of the patterns we also come across is that the businesses doing the best work are also the ones who’ve spent the least time telling anyone about it. They’re busy delivering work for their customers or clients, the website was built a few years ago and has been patched up since, and the case studies are either missing or so modest that they undersell what was actually achieved.
Meanwhile, a competitor might have less experience and a less impressive client list, but a website that explains clearly who they help, shows real examples of their work and makes it easy to get in touch. To someone comparing the two in a couple of browser tabs, the second business can easily look like the safer option, even if the reality is the other way round.
It’s often the small things that also tip the balance. A site that’s slow to load, looks awkward on a phone, has a blog that hasn’t been updated since 2021 or a copyright date in the footer that’s a few years out of date can all suggest a business that isn’t paying attention, which is rarely true but is very easy for a visitor to assume.
Your website needs to back up what you say
Some of the strengths businesses are most proud of are also the hardest for a visitor to see unless you spell them out. If you’ve invested in sustainability, for example, that’s a genuine reason for some customers to choose you, but only if they know about it. A vague line about “caring for the environment” won’t do much, whereas explaining what you’ve actually changed and what it’s achieved gives people something real to weigh up.
It’s also worth making sure your website is a sustainable one itself, because otherwise it can start to look as though you’re simply greenwashing. A site that’s heavy, slow and full of oversized images or videos doesn’t sit right next to a page about your commitment to reducing your carbon footprint, and it’s something people can easily check, with free tools such as the Website Carbon Calculator showing the carbon load of a page in a matter of seconds.
The same goes for a business that talks about inclusivity on a website that’s difficult to use with a keyboard or a screen reader. When what a site says and how it actually works line up, it’s far more convincing than any claim on its own.
And again, the same applies to quality, expertise and service. Specific results, named clients where you’re able to share them, testimonials that describe what it was actually like to work with you and a clear explanation of how you do things all help a visitor understand what makes you different, rather than leaving them to assume you’re much the same as everyone else.
Looking at your website the way a buyer would
If you suspect a competitor is winning work they shouldn’t be, it can be a useful exercise to put your website and theirs side by side and look at both as though you’re a customer who’s never heard of either business. Which one makes it clearer what they do and who they do it for, which one has more convincing evidence that they’re good at it, and which one would you feel more comfortable contacting?
Be open because It’s not always a comfortable comparison, but it’s usually a revealing one. In our experience, the gap between a good business and a business that’s seen as good is rarely about the quality of the work, and much more often about whether the website is doing that work justice.
In our experience, the gap between a good business and a business that’s seen as good is rarely about the quality of the work, and much more often about whether the website is doing that work justice.
What next?
If you know you’re better than your competitors but your website isn’t showing it, we’d be happy to take a look with you. Have a chat with us about web design and we can help you work out where your site might be underselling you and what would help it reflect the business you really are.





